Isn't it just the most magical thing when your little one's first tooth begins to peek through? But oh, the teething journey can be a bittersweet symphony of drool, tears, and sleepless nights. That's why finding the best baby teethers becomes our top mission, right?

Imagine this: Your sweetheart, happily gnawing on a safe, soothing teether, giving those tender gums some much-needed relief. Now that's a sight we'd all love to see!

But with so many options out there, how do you find the best one for your new one? Well, that's where I come in. I've been down this road before, and I've done the research so you don't have to.

How We Choose The Best Teething Toys For Babies

When it comes to choosing the best teething toys for babies here at Mother Bear Reviews, we don't just pick any old teether. We understand that as a parent, your baby's comfort and safety are your topmost priorities.

So, how do we choose? First, we look at material quality. It's a big no-no if it contains harmful substances. Next, we consider the design - is it easy for those tiny hands to hold? Then comes durability, because let's face it, our little ones are surprisingly strong!

Of course, we don't forget about functionality. Does it provide relief for those budding teeth? And lastly, we listen to you, other moms, and dads. Your experiences and reviews play a crucial role.

Each of our products is carefully chosen and independently selected by our editors. If you choose to purchase something from our selection, we may receive a share of the sale because we are an Amazon Associate and earn from qualifying purchases (at no additional cost to you), which helps keep us in business. We hope you find something that sparks joy!

Our Top Picks

Best Baby Teething Toy Overall
Manhattan Toy Winkel Rattle & Sensory Teether Toy

Best Budget Baby Teethers
Nuby Silicone Teethe-eez Teether with Bristles

Most Smooth Texture
Vulli Sophie The Giraffe

Best Teething Toys For Babies Ready For Solids
teetherpop No Mess Frozen Baby Teethers

Best Teething Toys For Breastfed Babies
Smily Mia Penguin Baby Teething Toys

Best Toothbrush Teething Toy
Baby Banana Infant Toothbrush

Easiest-To-Hold Teething Toy
Comotomo Silicone Baby Teether

Best Teething Toy Set
Fisher-Price Tiny Treats Gift Set

🤣
Teething babies:
Proof that nature has a cruel sense of humor, giving us the gift of parenthood and the curse of sore nipples!

Manhattan Toy Winkel Rattle & Sensory Teether Toy

Best Baby Teething Toy Overall

Manhattan Toy Winkel Rattle & Sensory Teether Toy

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

The Manhattan Toy Winkel Rattle & Sensory Teether Toy is a baby teething toy that is perfect for little hands. The maze of soft, continuous BPA-free teething tubes is mesmerizing for babies. This toy can be refrigerated for additional soothing comfort. It's a developmental toy that promotes clutching and two-handed play while the center cube with tapered corners encases a quiet but pleasing baby rattle to provide auditory stimulus.

Key Points To Keep In Mind

The Winkel is a time-honored classic that has been engaging babies and soothing fussy teethers for over 25 years. It's safety-rated for newborns and up, and measures 5" x 4" x 3.5". Parents love that it's lightweight, easily portable, and very easy for little hands to grab, hold, and rattle. Plus, Manhattan Toy is a trusted brand that has been creating imaginative toys for babies, toddlers, and kids of all ages since 1978.

In conclusion, the Manhattan Toy Winkel Rattle & Sensory Teether Toy is a reliable, safe, and fun toy for infants that will help ease the teething pain. It's perfect for on-the-go or at home, and will capture your baby's attention with its bright colors and interesting design.

Nuby Silicone Teethe-eez Teether with Bristles

Best Budget Baby Teethers

Nuby Silicone Teethe-eez Teether with Bristles

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

The Nuby Silicone Teethe-eez Teether with Bristles is a great option for your teething baby. The super soft 100% silicone fish-shaped teether is perfect for little hands to hold and provides multiple teething surfaces that aid in the eruption of new teeth. The massaging bristles gently massage baby’s gums and assist with the growth of new teeth.

The teething toy is suitable for children three months and older. Also, the unique textured design helps to massage sore gums. Plus, it comes with a hygienic carrying case to keep the silicone baby teether clean when not in use.

Key Points To Keep In Mind

This is an all food grade silicone teether that is BPA-free, safe and gentle for your baby. The multiple textures soothe, massage, stimulate, and clean baby's gums. It's easy to clean and the perfect size for little hands. Keep in mind that some babies may not like the fish shape or the massaging little bristles, so have a backup teether on hand.

In conclusion, the Nuby Silicone Teethe-eez Teether is a safe, effective, and affordable teething toy for your little one.

Vulli Sophie The Giraffe

Most Smooth Texture

Vulli Sophie The Giraffe

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

Sophie the Giraffe is a classic teether that has been loved by many babies for over 55 years. She is made of 100% natural rubber from the Hevea tree, which is soft and safe for your little one to chew on. She has a squeaker that keeps babies amused and stimulates their hearing. She also has dark and contrasting spots that provide visual stimulation and make her easy to recognize. She is very flexible and has lots of parts for a baby to chew on, such as ears, horns, and legs. She is perfect to soothe sore gums when teething.

Key Points To Keep In Mind

Sophie the Giraffe is not very cheap compared to other teethers, but she is worth the price for her quality and durability. However, you need to be careful with cleaning her, as she can get moldy inside if water gets into her squeaker. You should not submerge her in water or put her in the dishwasher. You should only wipe her with a damp cloth and mild soap. Remember to scan the QR code included in each box to authenticate your Sophie!

In conclusion, Sophie the Giraffe is a great teether that can help your baby through the teething stage. She is natural, safe, and fun for your baby to play with. She can also stimulate their senses and help them learn about cause and effect. She is a beloved toy that can become a familiar and reassuring object for your baby.

teetherpop No Mess Frozen Baby Teethers

Best Teething Toys For Babies Ready For Solids

teetherpop No Mess Frozen Baby Teethers

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

Teetherpop are USA-made teethers that are filled with your choice of liquid, such as breastmilk, purees, smoothies or water. You can also freeze them for soothing and refreshing homemade popsicles. Your baby will love drinking through the small slits in the reservoir, while the soft silicone massages their gums. Teetherpop has proven a hit among parents who have tried many other teething toys.

You don’t have to worry about any mess or choking hazards, as teetherpop has a patented no-mess design that meets all safety standards. Made from 100% medical grade materials and free from harmful chemicals like BPA, latex, and phthalates. Plus, they’re easy to clean and carry around.

Key Points To Keep In Mind

Teetherpop is not just a teething toy, but also a food feeder. You can use it to introduce your baby to different flavors and textures, as well as provide them with hydration and nutrition. However, you should always supervise your baby when using teetherpop and make sure the liquid is appropriate for their age and stage. If your baby is struggling to drink from the teetherpop, try a different teething toy. Also, replace the teether every 2-3 months or when it shows signs of wear and tear.

In conclusion, teetherpop is a great option for parents who want to give their babies a fun and functional teething toy that can also be used as a food feeder.

Smily Mia Penguin Baby Teething Toys

Best Teething Toys For Breastfed Babies

Smily Mia Penguin Baby Teething Toys

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

Smily Mia Penguin Baby Teething Toys are cute and colorful toys that soothe your baby’s sore gums and keep them entertained. They are wearable, so you don’t have to worry about them falling off or getting dirty. They are also easy to hold and chew, which helps with your baby’s motor skills and oral habits. Plus, they are made of food-grade silicone that is soft, elastic, and safe for your baby to nibble on. These teething pacifiers are perfect for babies aged 0-6 months and more than 1 million babies have approved them.

Key Points To Keep In Mind

This teether is a perfect replacement for finger sucking and chewing and is recommended by pediatricians. It helps with motor skill development and establishing good oral habits. It’s easy to wash, made of BPA-free food-grade silicone, and is dishwasher and freezer safe. The soft elastic silicone is safe for babies to nub on for teething pain relief. It’s soft enough to protect the baby’s gums but firm enough to massage them.

In conclusion, Smily Mia Penguin Baby Teething Toys are a great investment for new parents looking to soothe their teething babies.

Baby Banana Infant Toothbrush

Best Toothbrush Teething Toy

Baby Banana Infant Toothbrush

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

The Baby Banana Infant Toothbrush is perfect for introducing good brushing habits to your little one. With soft silicone bristles, it gently massages teeth and gums while developing good oral hygiene habits early on. The easy-to-grasp banana peel handles and 100% flexible silicone material prevent mouth injuries.

Plus, it’s durable and easy to clean in the top rack of the dishwasher. To sanitize it, you can boil it for ten minutes. It is made of BPA-free and non-toxic food-grade silicone that is safe for your baby to nub on for teething symptoms relief.

Key Points To Keep In Mind

This training toothbrush is designed for infants’ and toddlers’ small, sensitive mouths. It can be put in the freezer for a soothing numbing effect on painful gums. The “peels” allow you to attach a binky strap to prevent dropping. If it falls, it’s easy to rinse off, so your baby can keep chewing. The whole toothbrush measures 4.33" x 0.39" x 7.87", making it perfect as a first toothbrush. And it is perfectly safe if your if baby bites into it.

In conclusion, the Baby Banana Infant Toothbrush is a great way to teach your baby good brushing habits while providing relief for teething gums.

Comotomo Silicone Baby Teether

Easiest-To-Hold Teething Toy

Comotomo Silicone Baby Teether

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

Comotomo baby teethers are designed to mimic baby fingers and are made with food grade silicone that’s safe and perfectly chewy. They’re just long enough to reach the back molars at the back of baby's mouth, but are sensibly sized to prevent choking. They offer the perfect bite! The design is intuitive and easy for your little one to grab and hold. Plus, the simple one piece design and heat resistant silicone makes cleaning hassle-free.

Key Points To Keep In Mind

Comotomo baby teethers are durable and of high quality. They’re made with safety in mind and are easy to clean. Keep in mind that babies love to chew on their little fingers (and probably yours too), so this teether is a great option for satisfying that urge. In conclusion, Comotomo Silicone Baby Teether is a great option for parents looking for a safe and easy-to-use teether for their little ones.

Fisher-Price Tiny Treats Gift Set

Best Teething Toy Set

Fisher-Price Tiny Treats Gift Set

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

You’ll love the Fisher-Price Tiny Treats Gift Set! It’s perfect for little foodies ages 3 months and older. The set features 3 food-themed teething toys. The Pizza Slice Teether is gluten-, dairy-, and BPA-free with a textured silicone crust and crinkly “veggies and cheese”. The Taco toy has a crinkly shell with soft lettuce, tomato teethers, and ribbon “beans” and “cheese”. And the Pretzel Teether is BPA-free with textured “salt”. These toys are sized just right for small hands to grasp and help develop dexterity and hand-eye coordination.

Key Points To Keep In Mind

Keep in mind that these toys are designed for babies ages 3 months and older. They’re made of safe materials like BPA-free silicone and offer different textures for your baby to explore.

In conclusion, the Fisher-Price Tiny Treats Gift Set is a great choice for little foodies who love to explore new textures and flavors. It’s safe, fun, and helps develop important skills.

Best Teething Toys For Babies FAQ

What are some tips for buying teething toys?

Consider the type of teether you want to buy. Teething rings are classic, but these days you can also find different types of teethers, from teething toothbrushes to teethers that look like blankets or small toys.

Second, pay attention to the material and texture of the teether. Babies will happily chomp on anything they can get their hands on when teething, but they may be drawn to certain materials or textures over others. Many common teethers are made of food-grade silicone and are BPA-free, making them easy to clean and durable. Third, avoid amber teething necklaces and look out for mold.

Finally, consider investing in a few different teething toys to rotate through. What seems to help or interest your baby one week may be different the next. You can also put some toys in the freezer or fridge to provide a cooling sensation for your baby’s sore gums. Just make sure they are not too cold or hard for your baby to chew on.

What is the importance of teething toys?

Teething toys are essential for babies because they help ease teething pain. When babies start teething, they feel discomfort and become fussy. Teething toys provide a safe way for babies to apply pressure on their sore gums and find relief. Chewing and biting are two natural developmental processes of babies when cutting teeth.

Chewing on a teething toy made of soft silicone, rubber, or wood can soothe their gums. You can even chill the teething toy in the refrigerator for more pain relief. Teething toys are a perfect way to bring comfort to your baby’s life during this painful phase.

When do babies start to use teething toys?

Most babies start teething at 4-6 months, which is a great time to introduce teethers. Teething toys help reduce some of the pain your baby may be feeling because they provide a safe and clean chewing surface.

Chewing helps with the pressure of growing in those pearly whites! So, when you notice your little one trying to chew on everything in sight, it may be time for some teething toys. A baby teether can be safely used until the age of two years.

Should teething toys be hard or soft?

Some babies prefer hard toys that massage their gums and help them break through the skin. Others like soft toys that soothe their pain and comfort them. The best thing to do is to offer your baby a variety of teething toys and see what they like.

You can also put some toys in the fridge or freezer for extra relief. So long as the baby teethers aren’t too cold—think cool like the refrigerator, not the freezer—toys can calm sore gums. Just make sure the toys are safe, clean and not too small.

What are teething challenges in babies?

Teething challenges in babies can include irritability, disturbed sleep, drooling, chewing on things, sore and swollen gums, and low-grade temperature.

Your little one might seem fussier and may cry more than usual. Teething pain or discomfort may cause your baby to wake up during the night. It’s common for a teething baby to drool a lot when teething. Experts say the extra saliva can help soothe the tender gums.

Final Thoughts

As you can see, there are many great teething toys for babies that can soothe gums, relieve pain and stimulate their senses. But if you ask us, the best one overall is the Manhattan Toy Winkel Rattle & Sensory Teether Toy. It has everything a baby needs: a soft and flexible design, bright colors, a gentle rattle sound, and easy-to-grasp loops. Plus, it’s BPA-free and easy to clean. We are sure your baby will love it. So don’t wait any longer and get this amazing toy for your little one today.

Best Baby Teething Toy Overall

Manhattan Toy Winkel Rattle & Sensory Teether Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Thank you for reading Mother Bear Reviews, your favorite parenting blog!

Share this post